Global Adoption

Landmark Ruling in India Treats XRP as Property, Not Speculation

A Madras High Court judge barred WazirX from reallocating a customer’s XRP holdings and declared cryptocy qualifies as property under Indian law, setting a precedent that may reshape how exchanges handle user assets during insolvency proceedings across multiple jurisdictions.
As The Times of India reported on Oct. 25, Justice N Anand Venkatesh ruled that the entity operating WazirX cannot redistribute, apportion, or reallocate 3,532.30 XRP coins belonging to Rhutikumari, who purchased the assets by transferring funds from her Chennai bank account.
The court granted an interim injunction after finding jurisdiction, despite WazirX’s argument that a Singapore High Court-supervised restructuring scheme controlled the matter. Justice Venkatesh stated: “Cryptocy is treated as a virtual digital asset, and it is not treated as a speculative transaction.” The ruling cited Section 2(47A) of the Income Tax Act, which governs virtual digital assets, and found that cryptocy “is capable of being enjoyed and possessed (in a beneficial form) and is capable of being held in trust.”
WazirX contended that the platform does not own crypto wallets and that all users would receive pro rata compensation through a three-step process supervised by Singapore’s high court following a hack that halted withdrawals. The exchange argued that the Madras High Court lacked jurisdiction because the arbitration was seated in Singapore.
The court rejected that position. Justice Venkatesh noted that Rhutikumari transferred funds from India, accessed the platform from within the country, and therefore established that part of the cause of action arose within the Madras High Court’s territorial jurisdiction. The decision treats crypto holdings as distinct property rights rather than unsecured claims in a bankruptcy pool.
Courts in the US routinely treat crypto as property for remedial purposes, though regulatory classifications vary by agency.The New York state court issued a temporary restraining order over stolen USDC in the LCX case and authorized service by NFT.
Federal courts freeze wallets and seize crypto under Rule 65 and civil forfeiture statutes. Relief against exchanges depends on the contractual structure: customers holding assets in omnibus or “Earn” programs that transfer title recover less than those with proper custody arrangements, where platforms act as bailees, as seen in the Celsius Earn ruling. English courts recognize crypto as property and grant proprietary injunctions, freezing orders, and Bankers Trust disclosure against exchanges, including those overseas.
AA v Persons Unknown established the framework in a Bitfinex ransomware case, while Fetch.ai v Persons Unknown applied it to a Binance case. LMN v Bitflyer confirmed disclosure orders can reach foreign exchanges. Parliament moved to codify digital-asset property concepts following the Law Commission’s 2023 report, solidifying the legal foundation for such orders.
Terron Gold

Recent Posts

Bitcoin Crashes Below $72,000 as BlackRock Leads $1.44 Billion ETF Selloff and Crypto Liquidations Surge

Bitcoin plunged below $72,000 on Thursday as institutional investors continued withdrawing money from U.S. spot…

4 days ago

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang Resigns as Third Woman Emerges in Cheating Scandal Involving Alleged Chinese Spy

Nvidia co-founder and CEO Jensen Huang has resigned after 33 years leading the artificial intelligence…

4 days ago

BNY Partners With Figment to Bring Ethereum and Solana Staking to Institutional Investors

BNY (NYSE: BNY), one of the world's largest financial services and custody institutions, has partnered…

4 days ago

TRON, Tether and Chainalysis Launch New Crypto Crime Task Force After $450 Million Anti-Fraud Alliance Collapses

TRON, Tether and blockchain analytics company Chainalysis have launched the Digital Crime Task Force (DCTF),…

4 days ago

DOJ, Wall Street Banks and DeFi Giants Unite to Fight Illinois Crypto Transaction Tax

The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), major Wall Street banking organizations and leading decentralized finance…

4 days ago

OKX and NYSE Owner ICE Set November 23 Launch for Tokenized Stocks as Apple, Nvidia and Big Tech Opt Out

Cryptocy exchange OKX and Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), the parent company of the New York Stock…

5 days ago