The U.S. Department of Justice has rejected a key legal argument from Roman Storm, intensifying one of the most closely watched cases in crypto—and raising major questions about whether developers can be held criminally liable for decentralized tools.
Storm’s legal team attempted to use a recent Supreme Court ruling—focused on limiting liability for internet service providers—as part of a defense that Tornado Cash functioned as a neutral tool.
However, federal prosecutors dismissed the argument as “inapplicable,” stating the case involved civil copyright liability—not criminal charges like those Storm faces.
The DOJ emphasized that the situations are fundamentally different, arguing that the precedent cannot be used to justify dismissing the charges.
At the core of the government’s argument is that Storm was not simply a passive developer. Prosecutors allege that he:
This directly challenges the defense’s claim that Tornado Cash operated as a neutral, decentralized tool beyond the control of its creators.
Storm was previously convicted on one count related to operating an unlicensed money-transmitting business, while a jury failed to reach a verdict on additional charges tied to money laundering and sanctions violations—opening the door for a retrial.
Now, the DOJ’s rejection keeps the case moving forward, with potentially severe consequences if additional charges are upheld.
This case is shaping up to be a landmark moment for the industry, as it tests a fundamental question:
Can developers be held responsible for how users interact with decentralized software?
The outcome could:
This isn’t just a legal dispute—it’s a battle over the future of decentralized technology.
The bigger takeaway:
The line between code and responsibility is being redrawn in real time. And depending on how this case unfolds, it could determine whether building decentralized tools is protected innovation—or a legal risk.
Bitcoin plunged below $72,000 on Thursday as institutional investors continued withdrawing money from U.S. spot…
Nvidia co-founder and CEO Jensen Huang has resigned after 33 years leading the artificial intelligence…
BNY (NYSE: BNY), one of the world's largest financial services and custody institutions, has partnered…
TRON, Tether and blockchain analytics company Chainalysis have launched the Digital Crime Task Force (DCTF),…
The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), major Wall Street banking organizations and leading decentralized finance…
Cryptocy exchange OKX and Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), the parent company of the New York Stock…