U.S. Regulation

Digital Asset Market Clarity Act Moves to House Floor with Bipartisan Backing

A legislative proposal to establish a regulatory framework for digital assets in the United States, the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act, has advanced through two key House committees with bipartisan support. The bill, also known as H.R. 3633, cleared the House Financial Services Committee with a 32-19 vote and the House Agriculture Committee with a 47-6 vote, positioning it for consideration by the full House of Representatives. The legislation seeks to end jurisdictional ambiguity by assigning regulatory oversight of digital assets to either the Securities and Exchange Commission or the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.

The CLARITY Act introduces a new classification system to delineate these regulatory responsibilities. It defines a “digital commodity” as an asset intrinsically linked to a blockchain system and places these under the primary authority of the CFTC, which would oversee spot markets for such assets. In contrast, the SEC would retain its jurisdiction over the offering of “investment contract assets,” which are digital commodities sold or transferred as part of an investment contract.

This approach focuses on the nature of the transaction during capital-raising phases, rather than classifying the underlying asset itself as a security in perpetuity. A central element of the bill is the concept of a “mature blockchain system,” defined as a network not “controlled by any person or group of persons under common control.”

This criterion, which evolves from the “decentralized” concept in previous legislative efforts, would be used to determine when a project and its associated token could transition away from certain SEC disclosure requirements. The bill also contains language to formally protect the right of individuals to self-custody their assets and for developers of non-custodial software.

Proponents argue the legislation provides a necessary foundation for the digital asset industry to develop within the United States. In a statement, House Agriculture Committee Chairman Glenn “GT” Thompson said the bipartisan votes prove the timing is right for common-sense legislation that will finally bring certainty to the digital asset space. The bill’s sponsor, Representative French Hill, framed the legislation as a way to provide consistency and move away from the “regulation by enforcement” approach that has characterized the U.S. crypto landscape.

Industry organizations have also expressed support, with the Crypto Council for Innovation calling the bill’s advancement a “historic moment” for the digital asset industry and a major step toward clear rules that define agency roles and protect consumers. The American Bankers Association submitted a statement acknowledging the bill’s clarifications on matters such as the treatment of bank deposits.

Despite the support, the proposed framework faces criticism from former regulators and some lawmakers who question its effectiveness. Timothy Massad, a former CFTC Chair, has publicly warned that the CLARITY Act could create more confusion than clarity while potentially undermining decades of established securities law.

Per his analysis, the definition of a “digital commodity” is overly narrow and would “likely cover only a handful of tokens,” leaving a large portion of the market in a continued state of regulatory uncertainty. While acknowledging that the bill addresses important questions, Jennifer Schulp of the Cato Institute noted that it relies too heavily on grants of discretion to the agencies.

Concerns also exist that the bill’s definitions could create incentives for regulatory arbitrage, such as the creation of blockchains with minimal utility simply to meet the criteria for CFTC oversight. During committee markups, some Democratic members raised objections, citing worries about reduced financial safeguards and the potential for companies to evade regulation. The bill now awaits consolidation of the two committee versions before it can be scheduled for a vote on the House floor.

Terron Gold

Recent Posts

Bitcoin Crashes Below $72,000 as BlackRock Leads $1.44 Billion ETF Selloff and Crypto Liquidations Surge

Bitcoin plunged below $72,000 on Thursday as institutional investors continued withdrawing money from U.S. spot…

4 days ago

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang Resigns as Third Woman Emerges in Cheating Scandal Involving Alleged Chinese Spy

Nvidia co-founder and CEO Jensen Huang has resigned after 33 years leading the artificial intelligence…

4 days ago

BNY Partners With Figment to Bring Ethereum and Solana Staking to Institutional Investors

BNY (NYSE: BNY), one of the world's largest financial services and custody institutions, has partnered…

4 days ago

TRON, Tether and Chainalysis Launch New Crypto Crime Task Force After $450 Million Anti-Fraud Alliance Collapses

TRON, Tether and blockchain analytics company Chainalysis have launched the Digital Crime Task Force (DCTF),…

4 days ago

DOJ, Wall Street Banks and DeFi Giants Unite to Fight Illinois Crypto Transaction Tax

The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), major Wall Street banking organizations and leading decentralized finance…

4 days ago

OKX and NYSE Owner ICE Set November 23 Launch for Tokenized Stocks as Apple, Nvidia and Big Tech Opt Out

Cryptocy exchange OKX and Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), the parent company of the New York Stock…

5 days ago